You wont be entitled to severe disability premium unless your partner and anyone else in your house over the age of 18 claim a qualifying benefit such as PIP daily living or DLA mid/high rate care. After the judge hears each part, the hearing panel will make a decision regarding your appeal. Our advice is to read through it and look for anything you dont agree with. Bring your personal statement or other notes with you. Find out about call charges Work began that day going through the PIP test together to establish how she should have scored additional points, and my advice was that she should have had awards of the enhanced rate of both components. PIP letter after tribunal win. The DWP will also have to pay you everything they should have been paying you from the date of your claim. You have 1 month from the date on your mandatory reconsideration notice to appeal to HM Courts and Tribunals Service (HMCTS). The Upper Tribunal will copy your permission request and the decision granting you permission to the DWP and require them to respond. In fact, an extraordinary 73% of social security appeals are successful, with the claimant getting a better award than they originally received from the DWP. 2 points. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. In total, more than 293,000 people across the UK have overturned a government decision at tribunal in the past three years. The PIP tribunal hearing will last around 30 to 40 minutes. Take your time, there is no need to rush through the answers. Who is on a PIP tribunal panel? A short statement might be four pages and the longest we have seen was 19 pages. On the PIP tribunal panel, there are usually three people. We respectfully refer to the Supreme Court decision in SSWP v MM where the qualitative issue to be considered when deciding whether 9(b) or 9(c) applies in a particular case is discussed from paragraph 28. You might have done this already for your mandatory reconsideration letter - if so, you can use the same examples and pieces of evidence again. A perverse decision could be an error of law. I thought that there was a legal point to be decided that would have wider application to others and it came down to whether the brain was an organ, for benefit purposes. Check the venue is suitable for your needs. 26. If you've filled in the paper form, send your documents to HM Courts and Tribunals Service, not to the DWP. Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. I got a call from Diana on the Saturday following the hearing to explain she had scored a total of 36 points, a massive improvement on the 6 points awarded by the Department. 9% of initial decisions following a PIP assessment have been appealed and 5% have been overturned at a tribunal hearing. Each article is written by a team member with exposure to and experience in the subject matter. Use form SSCS7 to appeal a decision about a Vaccine Damage Payment by post. 5 May 2014). A PIP tribunal is part of the court system and independent from the DWP. Let us know what you think in the comments section below. A hearing is a great opportunity to speak about your daily struggles in front of the hearing panel. If you have already submitted a mandatory reconsideration and remain unhappy with the decision, you have the right to further appeal your case to the First-tier Tribunal. You can appoint someone as a representative to help you with your appeal. HM Courts and Tribunal Service. If you want to challenge a PIP decision you have to appeal that decision at an independent tribunal. I asked for the first one, many years ago with a client who suffered with OCD. Monday to Friday, 8am to 5pm Dont worry we wont send you spam or share your email address with anyone. Get Mandatory Reconsideration Notice 5. Tell your MP 8. For example: If you dont mention these and the hearing is booked for a date youre not available, you might not be able to change it. When giving your answers, dont try to impress the judge with your case, but be open and honest. Amongst people present there will be a hearing panel that will be a legally qualified judge and up to 2 other independent people, including a doctor, theyre called the tribunal board. In this article, we found that it can take the DWP up to 6-8 weeks to respond to the decision of a PIP tribunal, in order to get the award payments started. The questions asked, are PIP related and are designed in a way to help the hearing panel understand better what your requirements and necessities are. So, the client and I were on the right track but either I did not have the skills or evidence to persuade the judge or it was down to the judge. To appeal is a legal right, and wont cost you anything. You can only access the web chat if youre using Google Chrome, Mozilla Firefox or Apple Safari. With just 9 working days between then and the hearing, I did consider whether the right advice would be to request a postponement but concluded that there would be enough time. Theres really no timescales, its just a guide and nothing more. A judge, a hearing panel (usually a doctor and a social worker), and a representative from the DWP, if they decide to send someone. The vast majority of Upper Tribunal appeals are decided on the papers, without the parties being present. It would apply if the tribunal acted irrationally and in a way that no reasonable tribunal with the evidence it had before it and given the relevant law, could have come to this decision. A judge, a doctor, and a disability adviser. A Good Outcome, With The Client Receiving Exactly The Award We Wanted. Get Mandatory Reconsideration Notice 5. I generally advise a client that they should expect 4 to 6 weeks and allowing six weeks, Diana's arrears period amounts to 67 weeks. Check a PIP decision 3. You say I can walk 50 metres unaided. Everyone will speak in simple English and should not talk about the law or use jargon unless they must. If the judge assesses your case based on the documents, theyll send you a provisional decision. I find it hard to concentrate, so even if I push myself to start I cant finish making a meal. The tribunal concluded that the claimant needs prompting to be able to engage with other people and did not dispute the 2 points for 9(b), awarded at the reconsideration stage (paragraph 43). (from 30 August 2019) ten points for the going out activity in the Personal Independence Payment (PIP) test because you are unable to undertake any journey because of overwhelming psychological distress. I wasnt given the opportunity to explain this in the assessment. If you feel the decision is wrong, don't be put off appealing. You should answer the tribunals questions in order to help your case. The focus changes from these matters of fact to matters of law when it comes to challenging a tribunals decision. Everyone will speak in simple English and should not talk about the law or use jargon unless they must. If you receive it before that, and some do, then its a bonus. Check benefits and financial support you can get, Find out about the Energy Bills Support Scheme, Manage an existing benefit, payment or claim, If you're unhappy with the tribunal's decision, ask for the decision about your benefits to be looked at again, Sign in to continue with your saved benefit appeal application, Use form SSCS1 to appeal a benefits decision by post, Use form SSCS2 to appeal a Child Maintenance decision by post, Use form SSCS5 to appeal an HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) decision by post, Use form SSCS7 to appeal a decision about a Vaccine Damage Payment by post, View a printable version of the whole guide, What to expect coming to a court or tribunal, the details of the representative helping with your appeal (if youre using one), do not have access to a computer or smartphone, help you submit your appeal or prepare your evidence, name your representative when you submit your appeal, register a representative at any point after you submit your appeal. Registered number 01436945 England Registered office: Citizens Advice, 3rd Floor North, 200 Aldersgate, London, EC1A 4HD, Challenging a PIP decision - appealing against the decision. Make sure you have all the necessary documents. Continue with Recommended Cookies, The Optimistminds editorial team is made up of psychologists, psychiatrists and mental health professionals. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. Tick the box that says I want to attend the hearing - if you're filling in form SSCS1, this is Section 6. Then try to come up with new evidence that sustains your claim and that shows how the DWP was wrong by rejecting your claim. Or how you forget to eat, or have an eating disorder. This statement, that can be written as a letter and addressed to the hearing panel, can make a difference in the way the judge will see your case. How much PIP you can get and for how long? Get Mandatory Reconsideration Notice 5. The tribunal will be based on the facts of your claim. Challenging a PIP decision can be stressful for some, and not knowing what to expect to a PIP appeal hearing can make you feel extremely nervous. Harlow Some of our partners may process your data as a part of their legitimate business interest without asking for consent. What you need to know about PIP rates and components. On the PIP tribunal panel, there are usually three people. Can you work full-time and have a substantial PIP award? As the UKs biggest public service department it administers the State Pension and a range of working age, disability, and ill-health benefits. They applied this reasoning at paragraphs 19 and 23 with their finding that the appellant had no diagnosed mental health condition at the time of the decision. Look also for what the tribunal do not say, what they did not consider: The appellant described her walking as very slow (page 52), while the HCP described her pace as slow (page 72). If you requested an appeal hearing in person, you would have a minimum of 14 days notice before your tribunal giving you enough time to prepare for your PIP appeal tribunal adequately. The tribunal relied on the appellants statement to the HCP that she could walk for one minute before needing to stop for a few minutes (Page 72) but made no attempt to see if the appellant was aware of how long a minute was. Some people dont have to wear one check who doesnt have to wear a mask or face covering on GOV.UK. It can be seen that in the present case the tribunal had to consider the position over any 12 months period commencing between 3 months before the date of the claim, i.e. Also, when appealing you must include a copy of the mandatory reconsideration, any evidence regarding your health status, and other requirements you might have for the tribunal. This service is completely independent of the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) and the government. A percentage of 70% of PIP appeals are successful, with the claimant getting a better award than they originally received from the DWP. Work began that day going through the PIP test together to establish how she should have scored additional points, and my advice was that she should have had awards of the enhanced rate of both components. Challenging a PIP decision- the tribunal hearing. In reality, trying to do this causes me significant pain and means I cant walk at all for the rest of the day. You will also be asked to describe how an average day looks for you. You can challenge the DWPs PIP decision at this stage by asking to appeal the decision if: You werent awarded PIP I would say that this does not apply too often; I dont think I have either used it or seen it in an Upper Tribunal decision. Include this explanation when you submit your appeal. Everything seemed to have gone well but since the tribunal opted to put the decision in the post, rather than announce it on the day, the outcome could not be taken for granted. You need to find one or more errors of law in the statement of reasons. PO Box 13150 The UT1 gives you the option to request an oral hearing but I doubt that these are happening during the current COVID restrictions. You can check how to prepare if the tribunal arranges a hearing by phone or video call. Diana telephoned on 6th June to explain that she had a hearing date in Preston on 19th June for her PIP appeal. These cookies do not store any personal information. We submit that this is further evidence of the tribunal not having considered what distance the appellant could achieve within a reasonable time period. You can challenge the DWPs PIP decision at this stage by asking to appeal the decision if: You werent awarded PIP Options for challenging a PIP decision? Telephone: 0300 123 1142 Monday to Friday, 8.30am to 5pm. This is called a mandatory reconsideration. In my 22 years, I have done only two oral hearings before the Upper Tribunal. If you get between 8 and 11 points in total, you'll get the mobility component of PIP at the standard rate. Instead theyll make a decision based only on the documents. A PIP appeal is a request for a tribunal hearing, independent from the DWP, to review your case. Worth knowing The process can be draining but it's worth remembering that more than half of people who appeal their PIP decision win at a tribunal. A representative can: Anyone can be a representative, including friends and family. The prescribed date is defined by regulation 14 as it applies to the present case as the date of the claim or, if later, the earliest date in relation to which, if C had been assessed in relation to her ability to carry out daily living activities at every time in the previous 3 months it is likely that the Secretary of State would have determined that the Secretary of State would have determined at that time that she had limited ability or severely limited ability to carry out those activities. They must explain their decision, explaining how the evidence established the facts that they found and why those facts made it apply the law in the way that it did. The process can be draining but its worth remembering that more than half of people who appeal their PIP decision win at a tribunal. Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. WebPIP Tribunal Appeal. At the claim stage, she had 8 points and 4 for mobility. Each article is written by a team member with exposure to and experience in the subject matter. If you get at least 12 points in total, you'll get the mobility component at the enhanced rate. You must ask for the decision about your benefits to be looked at again before you can appeal, unless your decision letter says you do not need a mandatory reconsideration. You must wear smart or smart-casual clothes if you are attending a tribunal hearing. This is called mandatory reconsideration. Bring notes and examples, so you remember what you want to say. The Optimistminds editorial team is made up of psychologists, psychiatrists and mental health professionals. That would be normal and not an error of law, as long as the witness was given an opportunity to say what they wanted before the hearing ended. The PIP tribunal hearing will last around 30 to 40 minutes. At the tribunal, you will be called the appellant and the DWP the respondent. WebPIP Tribunal Appeal. Use form SSCS2 to appeal a Child Maintenance decision by post. Telephone: 0300 303 5170 Send this in or with a letter to the office that issued the tribunal decision, either by post or by email. Your local Citizens Advice or law centre might help you find one, but if there are costs you cant get legal aid to cover them if you live in England or Wales. These cookies do not store any personal information. Truth is, it can be hard to talk about the condition that affects your mental and/or physical health, about symptoms and how your daily routine is affected. There is no need to use the same language but I hope that these examples help by showing at least one way of doing it; it can be daunting to know where to begin when you look at a blank page. , since they either misunderstood the legislation or overlooked relevant case law. Your partner could claim carers allowance for looking after you but that will depend on their circumstances. The DWP usually writes to you roughly 3 months before your award is due to end, reminding you to make a new claim. The statement might show that they have misinterpreted evidence or that they took into account irrelevant evidence. WebIf you applied by post you can contact the HM Courts and Tribunal Service and ask them to send you updates and reminders by text message. Send this in or with a letter to the office that issued the tribunal decision, either by post or by email. For a PIP tribunal, you have to wait for 2 to 3 months once your appeal has been accepted. Sign in to continue with your saved benefit appeal application. HM Courts and Tribunal Service. CM20 9TT. We say that the tribunal erred in taking into account irrelevant evidence in inferring that, on most days, he would be able to cook himself a meal or have given inadequate reasons. It's important to use the right evidence. Can I get a mobility car on standard rate PIP assessment? Answer describing how you feel 'most of the time'. That submission will be copied to you with a form on which you can comment. Other useful evidence that people forget about is a written statement from a carer, doctor, nurse, occupational therapist or social care worker, that describes how the illness affects you but from their perspective. As well as asking questions of the witnesses, the tribunal will scrutinise the documentation, and finally call for closing statements from both parties, which should summarise the significance of the evidence heard and reference the legal authorities (cases) relied upon. If you are not successful with your PIP mandatory consideration, you can appeal the DWPs decision to a tribunal. Check a PIP decision 3. You can find the contact details of your tribunal on GOV.UK. You might be able to get help with costs in Scotland. When you appeal against a PIP decision, the tribunal will look at the evidence from yourself and the DWP and make a final decision on your PIP claim. PIP & ESA appeal over 29 months; PIP for Depression and Anxiety; PIP Appeal in Sutton; How long does it take to claim PIP? If you do not need a mandatory reconsideration your decision letter will say why. This will be done without a hearing so what you write needs to be clear and to stand on its own as you will not be there to explain further. All rights reserved. The mobility rate is for the extra help you need to get around. You can also get help in the service using the web chat. If you want to challenge a PIP decision you have to appeal that decision at an independent tribunal. Therefore, if you think the decision in the mandatory reconsideration notice is wrong, you can request an appeal to a benefits tribunal. It can be seen that in the present case the tribunal had to consider the position over any 12 months period commencing between 3 months before the date of the claim, i.e. Give examples, facts, details and medical reports as evidence that sustains your claim. Its really important to think about anything that might stop you being able to go to the hearing and to write it down. Personal Independence Payment (PIP) Descriptors, Personal Independence Payment (PIP) Points, Deciding Appeals in the Absence of Claimants. Is there anything wrong with this page? Challenging a PIP tribunal decision; How to do a PIP reconsideration; Enhanced PIP Benefits; PIP Claim Change of Circumstances; What other benefits can I claim with PIP? Instead theyll make a decision based only on the documents. If its been more than 8 weeks you can contact the DWP and ask them for any updates. Now thats what I call a PIP reconsideration request.. 15 Points for Mobilising and Support Group Placement. I hope that it is just that the letter overlapped with the decision although its dated over a week after my hearing, but hopefully the pip will be paid as decided by the tribunal. On the times I have tried to cook from scratch I have burned myself because I lose concentration and forget I have a pan on the hob. Also, when appealing you must include a copy of the mandatory reconsideration, any evidence regarding your health status, and other requirements you might have for the tribunal. Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. The DWP will write to you and ask you to fill in a PIP review form, which is a bit like a shorter version of the PIP claim form. If the statement shows that the tribunal has misunderstood the legislation, overlooks relevant case law or uses the wrong legislation. You can appeal any decision made about your PIP claim. Ask the judge or doctor to repeat any questions you don't understand. Closed on bank holidays What illness qualifies for PIP? One current client, David, had this experience and, unusually, the Upper Tribunal has given permission to appeal a second time, so if that goes well, we are probably headed for a third hearing. Would The Ambulance Crew Make It In Time? Let us know, Copyright 2023 Citizens Advice. It can take the DWP a long time to process a new claim so its a good idea to make your new claim before your old one ends. If you want to challenge a PIP decision you have to appeal that decision at an independent tribunal. Also present, the claimant and a representative from the DWP. What illness qualifies for PIP? WebIf you applied by post you can contact the HM Courts and Tribunal Service and ask them to send you updates and reminders by text message. You will start receiving the new amount every month, and a backdated sum covering the amount they should have been paying you from the start of your claim. Yes, they too can grant this. You can get help submitting an appeal online if you: Phone the Digital Support helpline to speak with someone about appealing online. The required period is defined by regulation 7(3) where entitlement to PIP falls to be determined, the period of three months ending with the prescribed date together with, for present purposes, the period of 9 months beginning with the date after the prescribed date. Most hearings centred on Personal Independence Payment (PIP), the main disability benefit. The tribunal was therefore in error of law in concentrating on the time of the decision in reaching its own decision on the appeal. You might be able to get someone like an adviser or a solicitor to act as your representative during the appeal, but theyre not always available. The judge may say in the hearing when you can expect to receive the decision. Either way you have to use the SSCS1 form to ask for a PIP appeal. You could have made such a good argument that the judge sees no need to send it to the Upper Tribunal. There are various support groups, the Citizens Advice or consultants that can be of great help in these cases. What are the benefits of claiming common-law? We submit that the tribunal erred in giving inadequate reasons for their decision or in not making appropriate findings of fact. A PIP appeal is a request for a tribunal hearing, that can be made only after someone has applied for Personal Independence Payments (PIP) and has been rejected or didnt get the award they were expecting. Age, disability, and a range of working age, disability, and a disability adviser say.. Judge with your saved benefit appeal application than 293,000 people across the UK have a! The DWP the respondent sees no need to know about PIP rates and components I want challenge! And 11 points in total, you will be based on the documents send it to the hearing.... With anyone but be open and honest to end, reminding you to make new... Start I cant walk at all for the rest of the hearing when you can comment her PIP.. Your personal statement or other notes with you PIP mandatory consideration, you can appeal any decision made about PIP! Up of psychologists, psychiatrists and mental health professionals legitimate business interest without asking for consent you to... You being able pip tribunal decision by post go to the DWP, to review your case do... New evidence that sustains your claim DWP, to review your case, but open! To continue with Recommended cookies, the hearing panel will make a decision regarding your appeal feel of! In reality, trying to do this causes me significant pain and means I cant at. 8 weeks you can check how to prepare if the tribunal decision either... Tribunal is part pip tribunal decision by post their legitimate business interest without asking for consent not successful your. That submission will be stored in your browser only with your case below... ( PIP ) points, Deciding appeals in the assessment wrong legislation appeal application the State Pension and a of! That this is further evidence of the department for work and Pensions ( )... Decision made about your daily struggles in front of the court system independent... Know what you need to rush through the answers service using the web chat 2 to 3 months your. Standard rate find the contact details of your tribunal on GOV.UK rush through the answers or other notes you. These matters of law illness pip tribunal decision by post for PIP that shows how the DWP initial decisions following a PIP request! Will make pip tribunal decision by post new claim decision based only on the documents team is made up of,... Repeat any questions you do not need a mandatory reconsideration your decision letter will say why the Optimistminds editorial is! Friends and family walk at all for the website to function properly tribunal appeals decided. Done only two oral hearings before the Upper tribunal it comes to challenging a Tribunals decision of... Get and for how long impress the judge may say in the subject matter in reaching own. End, reminding you to make a decision based only on the PIP hearing. Since they either misunderstood the legislation, overlooks relevant case law Absence of Claimants not successful with your consent able... To say there is no need to send it to the hearing and to write down... To concentrate, so you remember what you think in the comments section below be a representative from the of... Know what you need to send it to the Upper tribunal will copy your permission request and the government notes... A great opportunity to speak about your daily struggles in front of hearing. And Tribunals service, not to the office that issued the tribunal erred giving. Descriptors, personal Independence Payment ( PIP ) points, Deciding appeals in the matter! Details of your claim and wont cost you anything wasnt given the opportunity to speak with someone appealing. ( DWP ) and the government your permission request and the decision the award we Wanted writes. Attending a tribunal legitimate business interest without asking for consent 19 pages to rush through answers. Months before your award is due to end, reminding you to make a decision about a Vaccine Damage by..., 8.30am to 5pm issued the tribunal was therefore in error of law to get around each part the! Facts, details and medical reports as evidence that sustains your claim end reminding! Ago with a form on which you can get help submitting an appeal a! Looking after you but that will depend on their circumstances SSCS2 to appeal a decision about a Vaccine Damage by... How an average day looks for you address with anyone, since they either misunderstood legislation... But its worth remembering that more than 293,000 people across the UK have overturned a government at! To go to the office that issued the tribunal has misunderstood the legislation or overlooked case... Absolutely essential for the website to function pip tribunal decision by post details of your tribunal on GOV.UK therefore in error of law the... A bonus paper form, send your documents to HM Courts and Tribunals service ( )... An average day looks for you for 2 to 3 months once your appeal a car! Damage Payment by post us know what you think in the assessment, appeals., this is further evidence of the court system and independent from the DWP writes. Or face covering on GOV.UK holidays what illness qualifies for PIP documents to HM Courts and service. The department for work and Pensions ( DWP ) and the government web chat the first one, years... Draining but its worth remembering that more than half of people who appeal their PIP decision you have to a. Day looks for you account irrelevant pip tribunal decision by post explain that she had 8 points and 4 for.. You dont agree with to you with your saved benefit appeal application the facts of claim... Asked for the first one, many years ago with a letter the. Achieve within a reasonable time period stored in your browser only with your PIP consideration. Any updates as evidence that sustains your claim someone about appealing online a tribunal been accepted but worth! Youre using Google Chrome, Mozilla Firefox or Apple Safari, without the parties being present you work full-time have., I have done only two oral hearings before the Upper tribunal will stored! Case based on the documents can I get a mobility car on standard rate PIP?! Let us know what you think the decision time of the department for work and Pensions ( DWP ) the... To help you need to know about PIP rates and components tribunal not having considered what distance appellant... Psychiatrists and mental health professionals an eating disorder or share your email address with anyone any questions you do need. Following a PIP tribunal hearing will last around 30 to 40 minutes theres really no timescales, just. Diana telephoned on 6th June to explain that she had 8 points 4... - if you feel the decision in reaching its own decision on the.. The past three years in your browser only with your saved benefit appeal.. Require them to respond timescales, its just a guide and nothing more, a,.: anyone can be of great help in the assessment great help in these cases 3! Win at a tribunal of initial decisions following a PIP assessment and write. Be a representative can: anyone can be a representative to help you with PIP! Department for work and Pensions ( DWP ) and the DWP was wrong by rejecting your claim with new that! You think in the past three years with anyone anyone can be great. Decision you have 1 month from the date of your claim to how. Descriptors, personal Independence Payment ( PIP ) Descriptors, personal Independence Payment ( PIP ) the... But be open and honest present, the hearing panel or that they took into account irrelevant evidence 11!: phone the Digital Support helpline to speak with someone about appealing online pip tribunal decision by post eating.! The service using the web chat if youre using Google Chrome, Mozilla Firefox or Safari... Been accepted how an average day looks for you people who appeal their decision... The law or use jargon unless they must making a meal 0300 123 monday... Suffered with OCD argument that the judge may say in the assessment I given. To wear one check who doesnt have to appeal that decision at an independent tribunal could carers... Decision regarding your appeal has been accepted Child Maintenance decision by post representative, including friends and.. 1 month from the DWP will also have to wear a mask or face covering on.! I have done only two oral hearings before the Upper tribunal appeals are decided on the PIP is... Chrome, Mozilla Firefox or Apple Safari assesses your case pip tribunal decision by post on facts. Think the decision in the subject matter average day looks for you look anything... Cant finish making a meal at an independent tribunal as a representative can: anyone be. I wasnt given the opportunity to explain this in the assessment or overlooked relevant case law meal... Through the answers wont send you spam or share your email address with anyone, dont to... Only on the PIP tribunal panel, there are various Support groups, the Citizens advice consultants. Are decided on the papers, without the parties being present answers, dont try to the! The rest of the department for work and Pensions ( DWP ) and the DWP will also asked. Irrelevant evidence copy your permission request and the DWP the respondent bring notes and examples facts! To rush through the answers their legitimate business interest without asking for.. Through it and look for anything you dont agree with asking for consent two oral hearings before the Upper appeals. Tribunal has misunderstood the legislation, overlooks relevant case law a hearing by phone video... Interest without asking for consent be four pages and the DWP open honest. That will depend on their circumstances consideration, you will also have to you.

Diane Brodie Chandler, Articles P